| Newspaper Title | Publication City | State | Church Affiliations Designated by the American Antiquarian Society |
| Advent Herald and Signs of the Times Reporter | Boston | MA | Adventist |
| Alabama Baptist | Marion | AL | Baptist |
| Albany Christian Register | Albany | NY | Unitarian |
| Albany Religious Spectator | Albany | NY | |
| American Advocate | New York | NY | |
| American Baptist | New York | NY | Baptist |
| American Celt | New York | NY | Catholic |
| American Celt, and Adopted Citizen | Boston | MA | Catholic |
| American Celt, and Catholic Citizen | Buffalo | NY | Catholic |
| American Lutheran | York | PA | Lutheran |
| American Protestant | Boston | MA | |
| Anti-Universalist | Boston | MA | |
| Baltimore Christian Advocate | Baltimore | MD | Methodist |
| Bangor Journal of Literature, Science, Morals, and Religion | Bangor | ME | |
| Banner of Progress | San Francisco | CA | |
| Baptist | Nashville | TN | Baptist |
| Baptist | Memphis | TN | Baptist |
| Baptist Advocate | New York | NY | Baptist |
| Baptist Banner | Louisville | KY | Baptist |
| Baptist Recorder | Fairmont | WV | Baptist |
| Biblical Recorder | Raleigh | NC | Baptist |
| Boston Christian Herald | Boston | MA | |
| Boston Christian Observer | Boston | MA | Presbyterian |
| Boston Recorder | Boston | MA | Congregational |
| Buffalo Christian Advocate | Buffalo | NY | |
| California Christian Advocate | San Francisco | CA | Methodist |
| Catholic | Pittsburgh | PA | Catholic |
| Catholic Guardian | San Francisco | CA | Catholic |
| Catholic Herald | Philadelphia | PA | Catholic |
| Catholic Mirror | Baltimore | MD | Catholic |
| Catholic Observer | Boston | MA | Catholic |
| Catholic Press | Hartford | CT | Catholic |
| Catholic Sentinel | Portland | OR | Catholic |
| Catholic Standard | New Orleans | LA | Catholic |
| Catholic Standard | Philadelphia | PA | Catholic |
| Catholic Telegraph | Cincinnati | OH | Catholic |
| Catholic Union | Buffalo | NY | Catholic |
| Centennial Gazette | Ravenna | OH | |
| Central Catholic | Indianapolis | IN | Catholic |
| Central Christian Advocate | St. Louis | MO | Methodist |
| Central Christian Herald | Cincinnati | OH | |
| Central Methodist | Catlettsburg | KY | Methodist |
| Central Presbyterian | Richmond | VA | Presbyterian |
| Central Protestant | Greensboro | NC | Methodist |
| Charleston Advocate | Charleston | SC | Methodist |
| Christian Advocate | Raleigh | NC | Methodist |
| Christian Advocate | Nashville | TN | Methodist |
| Christian Age | Cincinnati | OH | |
| Christian Alliance and Family Visiter | Boston | MA | |
| Christian Banner | Fredericksburg | VA | |
| Christian Chronicle | New York | NY | |
| Christian Citizen | Boston | MA | |
| Christian Citizen | Worcester | MA | |
| Christian Contributor | Utica | NY | |
| Christian Era | Wheaton | IL | |
| Christian Era | Boston | MA | |
| Christian Freeman | Hartford | CT | |
| Christian Freeman | Chicago | IL | |
| Christian Freeman and Family Visiter | Boston | MA | Universalist |
| Christian Herald | Newburyport | MA | |
| Christian Herald | Middlebury | VT | |
| Christian Herald and Messenger | Albany | NY | |
| Christian Herald and Presbyterian Recorder | Cincinnati | OH | Presbyterian |
| Christian Instructor and Western United Presbyterian | Philadelphia | PA | Presbyterian |
| Christian Intelligencer | Georgetown | KY | |
| Christian Intelligencer | New York | NY | Reformed Dutch |
| Christian Intelligencer and Eastern Chronicle | Gardiner | ME | |
| Christian Journal | Exeter | NH | |
| Christian Journal | Utica | NY | |
| Christian Messenger | Monmouth | OR | |
| Christian Messenger | Dallas | TX | |
| Christian Messenger | Bonham | TX | |
| Christian Messenger | Middlebury | VT | |
| Christian Messenger | Montpelier | VT | Methodist |
| Christian Messenger | Newbury | VT | |
| Christian Mirror | Portland | ME | |
| Christian Neighbour | Gloucester | MA | |
| Christian Observer | Richmond | VA | Presbyterian |
| Christian Pilot | Portland | ME | Universalist |
| Christian Pilot | North Yarmouth | ME | Universalist |
| Christian Politician | Cincinnati | OH | |
| Christian Press | Cincinnati | OH | |
| Christian Rationalist | Boston | MA | |
| Christian Recorder of the African Methodist Episcopal Church | Philadelphia | PA | African Methodist Episcopal |
| Christian Reflector | Worcester | MA | Baptist |
| Christian Reflector | Boston | MA | Baptist |
| Christian Register | Boston | MA | Unitarian |
| Christian Register | Zanesville | OH | Unitarian |
| Christian Repository | Montpelier | VT | Universalist |
| Christian Secretary | Hartford | CT | Baptist |
| Christian Soldier | Boston | MA | |
| Christian Soldier | Providence | RI | |
| Christian Statesman | Washington (DC) | DC | |
| Christian Statesman | Washington (DC) | DC | |
| Christian Sun | Suffolk | VA | Congregational |
| Christian Telescope | Providence | RI | Universalist |
| Christian Times | New York | NY | |
| Christian Voices | Philadelphia | PA | |
| Christian Watchman | Boston | MA | Baptist |
| Christian Witness and Church Advocate | Boston | MA | |
| Christliche Zeitschrift | Chambersburg | PA | |
| Christlicher Kundschafter | Orwigsburg | PA | |
| Chronicle | New York | NY | Baptist |
| Church and Republic | Boston | MA | |
| Church Journal | New York | NY | |
| Church Union | Providence | RI | |
| Cincinnati Journal | Cincinnati | OH | Presbyterian |
| Cleveland Observer | Cleveland | OH | Presbyterian |
| Columbia | Milwaukee | WI | Catholic |
| Columbian Star | Washington (DC) | DC | Baptist |
| Columbian Star | Philadelphia | PA | Baptist |
| Congregational Herald | Chicago | IL | Congregational |
| Congregational Journal | Concord | NH | Congregational |
| Congregational Observer | Hartford | CT | Congregational |
| Congregationalist | Hartford | CT | Congregational |
| Congregationalist | Boston | MA | Congregational |
| Connecticut Catholic | Hartford | CT | Catholic |
| Connecticut Observer | Hartford | CT | Congregational |
| Connecticut Observer | Hartford | CT | Congregational |
| Courrier du Rhode-Island : Organe des Populations de Langue Francaise | Woonsocket | RI | Catholic |
| Cronica | New York | NY | Catholic |
| Cross and Journal | Columbus | OH | Baptist |
| Dayspring | Boston | MA | |
| Delaware Gazette, and Religious Informer | Delaware | OH | |
| Deseret News | Salt Lake City | UT | Mormon |
| Deseret News | Salt Lake City | UT | Mormon |
| Deseret News | Fillmore | UT | Mormon |
| Deutsche Freund | New York | NY | |
| Episcopal Register | Philadelphia | PA | |
| Essex North Register and Family Monitor | Newburyport | MA | |
| Examiner | Norwich | CT | Baptist |
| Examiner and Chronicle | New York | NY | Baptist |
| Farmer's Weekly Museum | Walpole | NH | |
| Fayetteville Luminary, and Reformed Methodist Intelligencer | Fayetteville | NY | Methodist |
| Fireside Journal | Boston | MA | |
| Franklin Post and Christian Freeman | Greenfield | MA | |
| Free Presbyterian | Chambersburg | PA | Presbyterian |
| Freedman's Journal | Boston | MA | |
| Frontier Guardian | Council Bluffs | IA | |
| Gambier Observer and Western Church Journal | Gambier | OH | |
| Genesee Evangelist | Rochester | NY | |
| German Reformed Messenger | Chambersburg | PA | |
| Gilford | Gilford | NH | |
| Golden Rule | Boston | MA | |
| Gospel Balance | Boston | MA | |
| Gospel Banner | Augusta | ME | Universalist |
| Gospel Banner | Woodstock | VT | Universalist |
| Gospel Messenger | Auburn | NY | Universalist |
| Gospel Messenger | Providence | RI | Universalist |
| Gospel Messenger | Syracuse | NY | Universalist |
| Gospel Messenger and Church Record of Western New-York | Utica | NY | Universalist |
| Gospel Sun | Boston | MA | |
| Guernsey Times | Cambridge | OH | |
| Herald and Torch Light | Detroit | MI | |
| Herald of Gospel Liberty | Newburyport | MA | |
| Herald of Gospel Liberty | Portland | ME | |
| Herald of Gospel Liberty | Portsmouth | NH | |
| Herald of Gospel Liberty | Philadelphia | PA | |
| Herald of Universal Salvation | New Haven | CT | Universalist |
| Herold des Glaubens | St. Louis | MO | Catholic |
| Holston Christian Advocate | Knoxville | TN | Methodist |
| Holston Methodist | Knoxville | TN | Methodist |
| I.C.B.U. Journal | Philadelphia | PA | Catholic |
| Independent Messenger | Boston | MA | Universalist |
| Independent Messenger | Milford | MA | Universalist |
| Independent Messenger | Mendon | MA | Universalist |
| Intelligencer Civil and Religious | Sangerfield | NY | |
| Interior | Chicago | IL | Presbyterian |
| Irish Citizen | Newark | NJ | |
| Ithaca Gazette and Religious Intelligencer | Ithaca | NY | |
| Jack Shepherd's Gospel Trumpet | York | PA | |
| Journal and Messenger | Cincinnati | OH | Baptist |
| Ka Elele | Honolulu | HI | |
| Ka Hoku Loa | Honolulu | HI | |
| Ka Lau Oliva | Honolulu | HI | |
| Katholische Volkszeitung | Baltimore | MD | Catholic |
| Katholisches Wochenblatt | Chicago | IL | Catholic |
| Key to Truth | Logansport | IN | |
| Kirk Anderson's Valley Tan | Salt Lake City | UT | Mormon |
| Leader | Boston | MA | |
| Leader | St. Louis | MO | Catholic |
| Lighthouse | Salem | MA | |
| Linn County Register | Marion | IA | |
| Lowell Observer | Lowell | MA | |
| Lutheran Observer, and Weekly Religious Visiter | Baltimore | MD | Lutheran |
| Maine Baptist Herald | Brunswick | ME | Baptist |
| Maine Free-Will Baptist Repository | Limerick | ME | |
| Maine Wesleyan Journal | Portland | ME | Methodist |
| Massachusetts Observer | Georgetown | MA | |
| Messenger | Philadelphia | PA | |
| Methodist | New York | NY | Methodist |
| Methodist Advocate | Atlanta | GA | Methodist |
| Methodist Protestant | Baltimore | MD | Methodist |
| Methodist Recorder | Springfield | OH | Methodist |
| Methodist Recorder | Pittsburgh | PA | Methodist |
| Metropolitan Record and New York Vindicator | New York | NY | Catholic |
| Michigan Christian Herald | Detroit | MI | Baptist |
| Michigan Christian Herald | Kalamazoo | MI | Baptist |
| Missionary | Mt. Zion | GA | |
| Missionary Visitor | Dayton | OH | |
| Monitor and Guardian | San Francisco | CA | Catholic |
| Mormon | New York | NY | Mormon |
| Morning Star and Catholic Messenger | New Orleans | LA | Catholic |
| Mountain Messenger, and Baptist Recorder | Morgantown | WV | Baptist |
| Mountaineer | Salt Lake City | UT | Mormon |
| National Baptist | Philadelphia | PA | Baptist |
| Nauvoo Neighbor | Nauvoo | IL | Mormon |
| New Church Herald | Cincinnati | OH | |
| New Covenant | Chicago | IL | |
| New England Puritan | Boston | MA | Congregational |
| New Hampshire Observer | Concord | NH | |
| New York Evangelist | New York | NY | |
| New York Freeman's Appeal | New York | NY | |
| New York Tablet | New York | NY | |
| New-England Baptist Register | Boston | MA | Baptist |
| New-England Baptist Register | Concord | NH | Baptist |
| New-York Baptist Register | Utica | NY | Baptist |
| New-York Christian Messenger | New York | NY | Universalist |
| New-York Freeman's Journal and Catholic Register | New York | NY | Catholic |
| New-York Observer | New York | NY | Presbyterian |
| New-Yorker Presse | New York | NY | Catholic |
| North Carolina Presbyterian | Wilmington | NC | Presbyterian |
| North Carolina Presbyterian | Fayetteville | NC | Presbyterian |
| Northern Christian Advocate | Auburn | NY | |
| Northern Christian Advocate | Syracuse | NY | |
| Northern Visitor | Brandon | VT | |
| Ohio Observer | Hudson | OH | Presbyterian |
| Ohio Observer | Cuyahoga Falls | OH | Presbyterian |
| Ohio Waisenfreund | Pomeroy | OH | Catholic |
| Old Hampshire Post | Northampton | MA | |
| Oriental: or, Tung-ngai san-luk | San Francisco | CA | |
| Pacific | San Francisco | CA | |
| Pacific Churchman | San Francisco | CA | |
| Philadelphia Recorder | Philadelphia | PA | |
| Philadelphian | Philadelphia | PA | |
| Pioneer of the Valley of the Mississippi | Shiloh | IL | |
| Poultney Gazette | Poultney | VT | |
| Presbyter | Cincinnati | OH | Presbyterian |
| Presbyterian Advocate | Pittsburgh | PA | Presbyterian |
| Presbyterian Home Missions | Denver | CO | Presbyterian |
| Presbyterian of the West | Springfield | OH | Presbyterian |
| Protestant Churchman | New York | NY | |
| Protestant Churchman | New York | NY | |
| Protestant Monitor | Greenville | IL | |
| Protestant Sentinel | Homer | NY | |
| Protestant Sentinel | DeRuyter | NY | |
| Puritan | Lynn | MA | |
| Radical | New Bern | NC | |
| Reformer | Moultonborough | NH | |
| Reformirte Kirchenzeitung und Evangelist | Cleveland | OH | |
| Religious Herald | Hartford | CT | |
| Religious Herald | Richmond | VA | Baptist |
| Religious Intelligencer and New Haven Journal | New Haven | CT | |
| Religious Recorder | Syracuse | NY | |
| Religious Recorder of Central and Western New York | Syracuse | NY | |
| Religious Reporter | Middlebury | VT | |
| Religious Times | Bloomington | IN | |
| Rhode-Island Religious Intelligencer | Providence | RI | |
| Richmond Christian Advocate | Richmond | VA | Methodist |
| Rising Sun | Richmond | ME | |
| Rocky Mountain Presbyterian | Denver | CO | Presbyterian |
| Rocky Mountain Presbyterian | Cincinnati | OH | Presbyterian |
| Salt Lake Tribune | Salt Lake City | UT | |
| Sandwich Island Gazette and Journal of Commerce | Honolulu | HI | |
| Southern Churchman | Richmond | VA | |
| Southern Churchman | Alexandria | VA | |
| Southern Cross | Savannah | GA | Catholic |
| Southern Presbyterian | Columbia | SC | Presbyterian |
| Southern Presbyterian | Charleston | SC | Presbyterian |
| Southern Presbyterian | Milledgeville | GA | Presbyterian |
| Spirit of Liberty | Pittsburgh | PA | |
| Spiritual Telegraph | New York | NY | Adventist |
| St. Louis Christian Advocate | St. Louis | MO | Methodist |
| St. Louis Luminary | St. Louis | MO | Mormon |
| St. Louis Observer | St. Louis | MO | Presbyterian |
| Standard | Chicago | IL | Baptist |
| Standard | Clarksville | TX | |
| Star in the East and New-Hampshire Universalist | Concord | NH | Universalist |
| Star in the West | Cincinnati | OH | |
| Star of Bethlehem | Lowell | MA | |
| Star of Bethlehem | Lowell | MA | |
| Sunday Democrat | New York | NY | |
| Taglicher Buffalo Volksfreund | Buffalo | NY | Catholic |
| Texas Presbyterian | Huntsville | TX | Presbyterian |
| Tract Journal | Boston | MA | |
| True of the Valley Shepherd or, St. Louis Know-Nothing | St. Louis | MO | |
| True Union | Baltimore | MD | |
| Trumpet and Universalist Magazine | Boston | MA | Universalist |
| Truth Teller | New York | NY | |
| Universalist Herald | Notasulga | AL | Universalist |
| Universalist Watchman and Christian Repository | Montpelier | VT | Universalist |
| Universalist Watchman, Embracing the Impartialist and Christian Repository | Montpelier | VT | Universalist |
| Universe | New York | NY | |
| Upper Missouri Advertiser | Independence | MO | Mormon |
| Vermont Christian Messenger | Northfield | VT | Methodist |
| Vermont Luminary, or, Orange Gazette, Masonic Reformer, and Christian Watchman | Randolph | MA | |
| Visitor and Telegraph | Richmond | VA | |
| Voix du Peuple | Manchester | NH | |
| Wahrheits-Freund | Cincinnati | OH | |
| Watchman of the South | Richmond | VA | |
| Watchtower | Newburyport | MA | |
| Weekly Council Bluffs Bugle | Council Bluffs | IA | Mormon |
| Weekly Recorder | Chillicothe | OH | |
| Western Baptist | Little Rock | AR | Baptist |
| Western Christian | Elgin | IL | |
| Western Christian | Chicago | IL | |
| Western Christian Advocate | Cincinnati | OH | |
| Western Christian Journal | Columbus | OH | Baptist |
| Western Episcopal Observer | Cincinnati | OH | Episcopal |
| Western Episcopalian | Gambier | OH | Episcopal |
| Western Home Journal | Detroit | MI | Catholic |
| Western Intelligencer, Religious, Literary, Political | Cleveland | OH | |
| Western Intelligencer, Religious, Literary, Political | Hudson | OH | |
| Western Pioneer and Baptist Standard-Bearer | Alton | IL | Baptist |
| Western Presbyterian | Danville | KY | Presbyterian |
| Western Star | Jacksonville | IL | Baptist |
| Western Watchman | St. Louis | MO | Catholic |
| Witness | Anderson | IN | Methodist |
| Wochentlicher Buffalo Volksfreund | Buffalo | NY | Catholic |
| World's Paper | Granville | VT | |
| Zion's Advocate | Portland | ME | Baptist |
| Zion's Herald | Boston | MA | Methodist |